Thursday, January 26, 2012

Does Soy Protein Cause Man Boobs?

No, there is nothing wrong with your eyes. You read it right. There has been lots of speculation that drinking lot of soy milk or consuming soy based foods and protein shakes actually cause man boobs. And therefore, if you are a guy, you should avoid consuming soy protein at all cost - unless you want to have man boobs. Someone actually asked me this other day and i was shocked. So is this true or is it just another urban myth? Lets take a look.

How did this hypothesis come about?
Soybeans are rich in molecules called "isoflavones" which has weak estrogen properties and has been used for years as a "natural" remedy for hot flashes in menopausal women. It is a known fact that many male transgenders take estrogen (not soy) to stimulate breast growth. Therefore, someone has decided to put 2 and 2 together and come up with the hypothesis that soy causes rise of estrogen, which causes man boobs. Is it true? Btw, in case you are wondering there is a scientific / medical term for man boobs and its called gynecomastia. Yup - didn't know that.

The fact is, this is a myth and there is no medical or scientific evidence to support this hypothesis. In 2004, an Italian study of kids raised on soy protein formula showed no gynecomastia, no early puberty, no changes in their bones and definitely no signs of screwed up hormones. In fact soy has been enjoyed by the world for thousands of years. So until there is scientific evidence of soy causing gynecomastia, all this is just another myth - like the myth that doing leg raises actually targets your lower abs. Of course if you were to surf hardcore body building sites, you will notice that soy based protein gets a really bad name. But most of the time, these are just opinions without any scientific proof.

So what actually causes gynecomastia? Here are some of the causes based on medical science:
  • Malnutrition and recovery from malnutrition can create a hormonal environment that is man boob friendly
  • Disorders in the male sex organ (testicles) which may be caused by genetics, aging, trauma, infection, aging
  • Other conditions that can promote altered hormonal environment such as chronic renal failure or hyperthyroidism.
  • Certain drugs and medications overdose - please check with your doctor on this.
Don't seem to see anything about soy here.

But isn't soy protein less effective for building muscle compared to whey protein?
Says who? I noticed lots of these comments on hardcore bodybuilding sites. Here is the truth on that as well. Several studies have been done to assess muscle gain in individuals using soy protein, whey protein and egg protein. The results - There was absolutely no difference between the three. Supporters of whey protein like to site BV (Biological value) as an indicator for the quality of protein. Unfortunately, BV is as outdated as BMI. Today most scientists use a different rating to score the quality of protein. Its called the PDCAAS--Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score. The highest possible score or rating is 1, meaning the highest and best quality protein for human consumption. Soy scores a 1 just like whey protein. So is whey still superior to soy? I can't see how.

I am a big supporter of soy based protein because i am lactose intolerant, and for years i trained without using any protein supplement at all. Today i use a soy based protein supplement because it just takes the guess work out of nutrition. For me, my soy based protein supplement gives a high protein content (80% of it is protein) without the unnecessary calories. Now who wouldn't want that? And like i shared earlier, from that protein shake, i can make it into a weight gainer or even a meal replacement shake. I do hope this post has shed some light on soy protein and busted the myth that many people have with regards to soy protein.

So if you have been consuming loads of soy based products like tofu, soy milk and tempe, don't worry. You don't need to go down to Victoria Secret to check out their latest collection of bras. The fact is, soy protein does NOT cause man boobs. As usual, look forward to hearing your comments.

12 comments:

David Haas said...

Hello,
I have a question about your blog, could you email me?
David

daniel yusof said...

ive heard this myth sometime ago n i did avoid soy. but at the same time im not fully belief at the myth.

but what a relief after reading this.

Aizan Suhaira said...

I've always believed the bad rep soy gets is undeserved. Like what you have mentioned, soy has been consumed by ancestors since hundreds if not thousands of years back. They managed to procreate and there were no talk about sprouting man boobs back then right?

But I have a suspicion that MAYBE soy is not very suitable for caucasians relative to asians. Soy has been staple food for asians. But nlt sure about our caucasian counterpart. Maybe our genetics play a role on how it reacts with the stuff in soy?

Me... I have no choice but to take soy as i am allergic to milk. And i have gained some decent musce mass on soy. So i have no complaints.

Rajan said...

David: sure thing. You can email your inquiry to rajanrj@hotmail.com

Daniel: yup. It's important to always check the facts.

Aidan: yup...I too believe that maybe soy is not ideal for Caucasians. But it's just an opinion at the moment. Need to research it first though

So you are Another lactose intolerant friend.

Ooze said...

Male breast reduction (also known as gynecomastia) is the surgical correction of over-developed or enlarged breasts in men.During an excision procedure, the incision is made either on the edge of the nipple (areola) or in the underarm area. The surgeon cuts the excess glandular tissues,skin and fats from around the pigmented area surrounding the areola and from the sides and bottom of the breast.
Liposuction is also used to remove excess fat, a hollow tube (cannula), is inserted directly through the existing incisions. The cannula is attached to a vacuum pump to suction out the fat.

http://malebreast-reduction.blogspot.com

Ooze said...

Male breast reduction (also known as gynecomastia) is the surgical correction of over-developed or enlarged breasts in men.During an excision procedure, the incision is made either on the edge of the nipple (areola) or in the underarm area. The surgeon cuts the excess glandular tissues,skin and fats from around the pigmented area surrounding the areola and from the sides and bottom of the breast.
Liposuction is also used to remove excess fat, a hollow tube (cannula), is inserted directly through the existing incisions. The cannula is attached to a vacuum pump to suction out the fat.

http://malebreast-reduction.blogspot.com

lauryn said...

my friend has talked about the side effects of soy protein in diet and has suffered the side effects of it himself.

maybe you could ask him more about it. His name is Stevie Tan and owner of the LeanFactor Program.

Shawn OKC said...

I have struggled with my weight for years. I recently stumbled upon exercises that are helping me. See what you think. http://85-classic-special-talkingpoints.com/

inGreatDeal said...

I have to show this article to my friend, he has man boobs and he doesn't know how to get rid of it. Thanks.

Unknown said...

Boobies growth. Gynecomastia surgery you want to be. How mezde─či a doctor from Turkey
Jinekomasti

hams john said...

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.
Gynexin Ingredients- A Way to Masculine Appearance

Prushotaman Batumalai said...

Bro, I am lactose intolerant as well.. do you have recommendation as to a good soy protein supplement
?